Srimathe Rangaramanuja Mahadesikaya Namaha
Based on EnpaNi 837 adiyen got a question. Heart surgery is fine understandable but when heart transplant is done how will the athma behave?
Will it exit and re-enter body? Or will it hide somewhere? Adiyen understand that consciousness still persists so it has to be the same athma.
Please clarify Swami
Dasanudasan
Adiyean!
My understanding (based on Swamiji’s pravachanams)is that Aathma is not bound with any of the organ. Same as the Param Aathmaa’s position. Both Aathma and Paramaathmas are existing inside this Pancha Boodha Sareeram. Might be positioned near the heart… but not bound. Hence, the question of what if the oran is removed or transferred would not be valid.
Ramajuja Dhasan.
Sri:
Romam neidhu onbadhu vassal
Stitched with hairs inside 9 exits. The Athman’s prabhAvam is spread all over shareeram that’s why we realise pain – Velukkudi Krishnan Swami.
Then why is AthmA related to hrudhaya kamalam? If hrudhayam is not the organ then is it the manas?
In Nrusimha avatharam , when hiranyakashipu came in search of Sriman NArayana, Vishnu says to Lakshmi “Let’s hide inside his heart that’s the only place he doesn’t know” – Sri Mukkur Lakshmi NrusimhAchAriyAr
Near heart is not convincing explanation to adiyen. AthmA is NOT prAnan. So body may live during heart transplant (irrespective of consciousness). Of course athmA cannot be seen within heart if we cut it open but it does not mean athmA does not reside within heart when shAstrAs says so.
“Might be positioned” is not an appropriate answer adiyen. It may not be bound as it is not sthoolA but why inside and outside body comes into picture when it’s unbound?
Anthar bahischa tat sarvam vyApya nArAyana sthitha:
What is inside and outside when body cannot bind something?
Adiyen is missing something, adiyen
Dasanudasan
Sri:
Got answer adiyen.Ref: EnPaNi “What happens to bhooma devi after destruction of earth?”
Bhumi different from bhuma devi
Varuna different from varuna devan
Sooryan different from Soorya Narayanan
Former = Physical
Latter=Athman
Meaning:
the physical changes does not impact athman
Dhanyosmi
Dasanudasan
Srimatae Ramanujaya Namaha,
Bhakta is welcome.
Sri Velukkudi Krishnan Swami ThiruvAdigalaey Sharanam,
Sarvam SriKrishnarpanam Asthu,
