Sri Ramanuja Munaye Namaha,
Sri Velukkudi Krishnan Swami Guruve Namaha,
Asmadh Sarva Gurubhyo Namaha,
Madhippukuriya Sri Velukkudi Krishnan Swami ThiruvAdikku Pallaandu Paadi Thiruvadigalaey Sharanam,
Swami,
In Upanyasam, Devareer has said,
“Acharya Thirumeni Rakshanam, SHishyanin Kadamai,
Shishyanin Athma Ujjivanam, Acharyanin Kadamai”.
Vardhamana Upakara Acharyan surrenders ourselves Jeevathma to Lotus feet of Uddharaka Acharyan Ramanujar, and Swami with HIS Karunai Ullam grants Moksham and Nithya Kainkaryam for us in same birth.
Adiyen question is related to Vardhamana Upakaraka Acharyas Health, Thirumeni Rakshanam. Acharyas health sometimes becomes in difficult situation in this Smasaram “Novu Saathi kolkirar”.
Adiyen has heard two reasons for Acharyas health issue is due to:
1) Shishyas Paapam attacks Acharyans health, and Acharyan health deteriorates, Or,
2) Acharyan is so devoted in kainkaryam, and thinks Kainkaryam in this Samsaram itself is more than SriVaikuntam. Hence, Perumal gives Acharyan some health issue to divert Acharyas attention from Kainkaryam in this Samsaram, so Acharyan come back to Nithya Kainkaryam in SriVaikuntam. Like, Thirumalai AnathAzhwan Pillai Swami situation as seen in GuruParamparai.
**************************
Three Questions Swami,
************************
<A) The case 2) is PErumal decision>
This is a dharma Sankatam situation for Shishyass as well, and Why does Acharyan needs to suffer health to go back to SriVaikuntam , when Acharyan is already doing Kainkaryam in this Samsaram joyfully. Please clarify Swami.
************************
<B) The case1) is due to Shisyas act>
This is also a Dharma Sankatam Situation. Sometimes a Bhakta’s actions is like frog jumping 2 steps and falling back 3 steps in a well, so accumulation of Paapam persists, but Perumal gives some Punishment depending up on the intensity, like “Rajakumaranukku Kidaikkum Laghu DHandanai Pole”, since we are Sharanagathas on Acharyas Lotus feet”. Still, Acharyans health suffers sometimes, means, Acharyan is taking the burden of our Paapams.
So, Can EACH of the Shishyaas of the particular Acharya PAramparai, honestly ask Perumal to give their own respective Paapams back to ourselves that caused Acharyan Health issue, so Acharyas pain is releived. LIke Senior Shishyaas to newly joined Shisyass should ask PErumal their own paapams back. Is this something, that we can ask PErumal directly, or Acharyan have to approve before we ask Perumal. Please clarify Swami. Can this also be considered as Acharyan Thirumeni Rakshanam.
************************
<C) Why Samsaram needs to be considered as Goram when Perumal/SriKrishna is the one who gives us Punishment for our mistakes. It should also be considered as one way of BhagavAt Anubhavam>
The reason why adiyen ask this question is, many fear about Perumal Dhandanai (Punishment). Adiyen feel, before Prapatti, for any mistakes that we do, Perumal punishes either in Hell or in Same janma in Bhoomi depending up on the intensity of crime. But, we were not aware who is punishing us. But after Prapatti, we know, Perumal is the one who gives punishmnet for our mistakes. SO, isn’t it getting Punishment from Perumal should also be considered as ‘BhagavAt AnubhavAm’, Since in SriVaikuntam, it is Suddha SatvaMayam (No Rajas/Tamas) and we don’t make mistakes and hence we cannot enjoy Perumal’s THIS PARTICULAR kalyana Gunam “Nigrahamum Anugrahatthin Seikaye (Punishment is Blessing in Disguise)“. We can enjoy this particular Kalyana Gunam, only in this Samsaram. SO why does Alwar and Acharyas says, this Samsaram is goram/dangerous.
- Samsaram is goram, only if we don’t want to enjoy Perumal’s Kalyana Gunam “Nigrahamum Anugrahatthin Seikayye”.
- Samsaram is Sweet, if we want to enjoy Perumal’s Kalyana Gunam “Nigrahamum Anugrahatthin Seikayye.
[Swami,
adiyen intention is not tell, we need to make mistakes knowingly, so we can enjoy Perumal/SriKrishna’s Kalyana gunam ‘Nigrahamum Anugrahatthin Seikeyye’ in this Samsaram which is not available in SriVaikuntam. Is this thought process correct or wrong is the question. Is this something Acharyas have debated in the past.]
Please clarify adiyen thoughts Swami and provide Anugraham.
********************************
Adiyenai Shamikka Prarthikkiraen,
Adiyen Sri Velukkudi Krishna Dasan,
Acharyan ThiruvAdigalaey Sharanam,
Chaitra Aarudra Sambhavam Vishnoho, Dharshana Stapanotsavam,
Thundeera Mandala Sheha Moordhim, Ramanujam Bhaje Jagadh Guruve Namaha,
Uyya Oraey Vazhi UdayvAr ThiruvAdi,
Sarvam Sri Krishanrpanam Asthu.