maitreyi gargi

Updated on April 15, 2018 in General
2 on April 1, 2018

I know and have heard from swamy’s upanyasams that women cannot read Vedas and I do not debate it. But recently, I read some indologists say that in Vedic times women also read Vedas and were also initiated into studying the Vedas and this rule is only recently formed. They frequently quote two personalities that they claim are mentioned in Rg Veda, (I think it was Rg Veda, not too sure which one they quote) Maitreyi and Gargi, who studied Vedas and I believe Maitreyi also debated with Yagnavalkya on Vedanta. 

I got confused by this. Who are these personalties? Are they mentioned in our scriptures? Did they read the Vedas and if so, was it because of some special circumstances? I have also heard that women cannot read the Vedas means they cannot recite it but it does not mean they cannot listen from acharya and learn the  meanings. So did Maitreyi and Gargi listen from acharya without them reading/reciting it?

I apologize if anything I asked is offensive in anyway.

Namaskarams at the lotus feet of all bhagavathais and bhagavathas

 
  • Liked by
Reply
1 on April 2, 2018

Swami has answered in today’s enpani (#975) dated April 2nd 2018

Summary of main points:

Mention of women in vedas does not imply they recited. they have asked questions to rishis.

Vedas recommend certain path to certain people (brahmanas,kshatriyas etc) (to men , women etc)

Why it did not recommend has to be accepted in good faith , in the same way we accepted vedas in first place. Vedas are meant for only those who have faith in them.  So those who have faith in vedas must also accept in faith that portion of vedas which states how and who and when should it be recited.

Swami has considered all possible questions around this topic and answered very clearly.

Adiyen

 

 

on April 15, 2018

Thank you for your response enpanifan swamy. Thank you Velukkudi swamy. My doubts are cleared. Namaskarams!

Show more replies
  • Liked by
Reply
Cancel