Why don’t our guru parampara have rishis ??

Updated on November 22, 2022 in Acharyas
12 on November 6, 2022

Srimathe Ramanuja namaha 🙏

Swamy, Recently I met an advaita. He said his guru parampara contains rishis. So, he said his guru parampara is only authentic. But, I can’t accept.

Advaita guru parampara has – Vasishtha, shakti, parasara, veda vyasa, sukar.

Dvaita guru parampara has- Sanakadi kumaras (Sanaka, Sananda, Sanatana, sanat kumara) and Durvasa munivar.

That advaiti also said, ” His guru parampara has acharya from all four yugas”

Why don’t our guru parampara have rishis ? Why don’t our guru parampara have acharyas from all 4 yugas ??

Adiyen Ramanuja dasan 🙏🙏

 
  • Liked by
  • Govindan Narayanan
Reply
2 on November 8, 2022

Srimathe Ramanujaya Namaha,

Namaskaram Sundara Ramanuja dasan BhagavAta,

Swami Ramanujacharya’s VishistaAdvaitam followers doesn’t follow Rishis in GuruParamparai though Acharyas refer to some of the Rishis’ works (Vashista, Parasara, Shakti, Veda Vyasa, Sukar etc)…. because they follow:

Anga Prapatti: Means to Surrender to SrimanNarayana to remove the Obstacles (Karma’s) that is obstructing them to start the Karma-Gyana-Bhakthi yoga maargham, which will yield results, after many million janmas,ONLY  if PERFECT meditation like “Thaila Dhaaravath (Streamlined Oil flowing with no dripping) method is followed without getting into any Materialistic activities like Job, Family etc…. So it is Rishis Effort (Upayam/Route) to attain BhagavAn (Upeyam/Premeyam). So Karanam Thappinaal Maranam in this Maargham, very risky due to our effort.

Example: Supreme Almighty GOD Sriman Narayana took SriRama Avatar. HIS Acharya is a Rishi Vashista. In actual, SriRama took Manushya Avatar, so HE should have attained Moksham only through HIS Acharya Krupai Vashista, but Vashista is still in this Samsaram, didnot go Moksham, since he follows Karma-Gyana-Bhakthi Yoga maargham, which will take many Janmas. So SriRama had to take off HIS Manushya mask and go to SriVaikuntam as ParamAthma itself, since HE can’t wait till HIS Acharya gets Moksham. Does this help, why we dont follow Rishi’s.

But, We Ramanuja Dasas follow Swathantra Prapatti on Acharya Ramanuja’s Lotus feet, since SriRama has said to Swami RamanujA that HE will give Moksham to all of HIS Sambhandhis in Gadya Trayam. This is not promised by BhagavAn to any other Acharyas of any other sampradhayam. So here, it is BhagavAn’s Krupai received through Acharya RamanujA’s Lotus Feet (Upayam/Route) to attain BhagavAn (Upeyam/Acharya ThiruvAdi/Premeyam). Our Effort is not thee here for Moksham, so we are safe, NO risk.

So, Acharya’s in our GuruParamprai don’t bring in the Rishi’s in GuruParamparai because their Philosophies will dilute and confuse the people more especially in Kaliyuga who are already ignorant and will deviate from Nithya Kainakryam/SriVaikuntam.

Also, Adaviti’s dont accept Moksham/SriVaikuntam. They are Shoonya vaadham, who worship many deities, ultimately leading to a nameless, formless, attributeless absolute. Is this confusion necessary for a JeevAthma who is looking for a relief from this Material world and do Kainakryam to BhagavAN Sriman NarayanA. So, AcharyAs don’t prescribe the Rishi Philosophies.

These Sampradhayam’s follow Bedha shruti and Abedha shruti from Upanishads, which is why all these confusions exist, called as Rishi Samprdhayams. But Swami Ramanuja pulled the Kataka Shruthi from Upanishads which tells clearly about ParamAthma, JeevAthma (Chit) and Achit as in SriBhashyam and in Shatha-Dhooshani by Swami Vedantha Desikar. So, we don’t have any confusion, because it Starts from 1st Acharyan Sriman Narayana (ThayAr-Perumal) straight to Swami VishvaksenAr, then NammAlwar and so on to Present Acharya, and NO rishis as below GuruParamparai Thaniyan.

Lakshmi Natha SamArambhAm
NAdha yAmuna MadhyamAm
Asmad AchArya ParyanthAm
Vande Guru paramparAm

So, lets pray on Swami RamanuJAr’s Lotus Feet that, at some point let all the ignorance in other Samprdhayams get removed by Swmai RamnujAr’s grace and they come for Kainkaryam here in Material world and they acknowledge the existence of SriVaikuntam rather than Shoonya Vaadham meditation as seen below which is no useful for a JeevAthma.

Adiyen (ElayaAlwar) Srinivasa (DhoddayacharyAr) Dasan.

on November 10, 2022

Swamy very nicel explained: adiyen neechan having one small query: In your above example you mentioned RAMA was waiting due to his acharya was enjoying the Samsaram ! And our acharya Ramanuja already attained Mokasha hence we will get direct flight to vaikuntam ! But both margam wants us to reroute via Acahryas only! Difference of practice is different due to Self try/ Surrender to bagwan lotus feet. Little confused with surrendering to Bagwan lotus feet vs Acharyas sampandham ! Being we all are Ramnujas sambandham should i forget about surrendering to bagwan lotus feet. Kshamikavum Adiyens only saviour is my acharyas. But for general people questions asking here… Kshamikvaum

on November 14, 2022

Understood myself “When we surrender to Baghwan we go with lot of SIN”, but “when surrender via Achrya Baghwan dont see our mistake”. I recalled Swamy velukkudi sayings and understood the benefits, 

Show more replies
  • Liked by
Reply
Cancel
0 on November 8, 2022

🙏 . Thanks a lot for your detailed explanation, elayalwar swamy. Now, I understood clearly by your kind grace.🙏🙏

Adiyen 🙏

  • Liked by
Reply
Cancel
2 on November 14, 2022

Swami,

I happened to refer to VedArtha Samgraha, where Bhagavad RAmAnujar, attests about 1. Baudhayana; 2. Tanaka; 3. Dramida; 4. Guhadeva; 5. Kapardi; and, 6. Bharuci as the predecessor of VishishtAdvaita siddhAntam.

So it looks like there is a link between Lakshminatha (bhagwan himself) and Sri NAthamunigal and Sri YAmunAchArya before the wisdom was passed onto Bhagavad RAmAnujacharya, though they were not rishis per se.

– Adiyen

on November 15, 2022

They were not rishis but munivars
Adiyen don’t know difference but let Sri Velukkudi Krishnan Swamy explain.

Some EnPaNi audio Swamy explained difference between Rishi , munivar, yagam , yagnyam etc I forgot.

Dasanudasan

on November 15, 2022
So it looks like there is a link between Lakshminatha (bhagwan himself) and Sri NAthamunigal and Sri YAmunAchArya before the wisdom was passed onto Bhagavad RAmAnujacharya, though they were not rishis per se.From srivats

True, adiyen did mention they were not classified as rishis! 

– Adiyen

Show more replies
  • Liked by
Reply
Cancel
1 on November 15, 2022

Srimathe Rangaramanuja Mahadesikaya Namaha
Srimathe Sri Varaha Mahadesikaya Namaha
Sri Velukkudi Krishnan Swamy Thiruvadigaley Sharanam

Sri:

We have munivars in Guru Parampara

Naada Muni
Yamuna Muni

Lakshmi Natha SamArambhAm
NAdha yAmuna MadhyamAm
Asmad AchArya ParyanthAm
VandEy Guru ParamparAm

Also Yogeshwaran Thirumazhisai Azhwar who tested lord Shiva if he is capable of Moksham

Dasanudasan

on November 15, 2022

In fact Sri Ramanuja himself a Munivar in our Sampradayam.

Srimath Veda MArga PrathistApanAchAryANAm
Parama Hamsa ParivrAjakAchAryAnAm
Sarva Tantra SwathanthObaya VendAnthAchAryAnAm
Sri Bhagavath RAmAnuja SiddhAntha NirDhAraNa SArva BowmAnAm

Sriman NAdha Muni
Srimath Yamuna Muni
Srimath Ramanuja Muni

Roopa Munitraya SiddhAntha SthApakanAchAryANAm

Srimath Andavan
Sri Rangaramanuja Mahadesikan
Sri Varaha Mahadesikan

Dasanudasan

Show more replies
  • Liked by
Reply
Cancel
2 on November 22, 2022

Adiyen has a bit of confusion!

If our sampradAyam does not have rishi paramparai, then who are Atri, Bhrigu, Kashyapa, and Marichi? 

VaikhAnasa AgamA does talk about the doctrine of worshipping bhagawan preached by Sage Vikhanas to these Rishis!

Even this AgamA comes under the purview of Sri Vaishnavism only!

How can a superset (Sri Vaishnavism) have no rishi paramparai but its subset (Vaikhansam) have it?

– Adiyen

on November 22, 2022

Swamy, agama is different from sampradayam.

Agama teachs how to worship bhagavan in temples while sampradayam tells philosophy, siddantam and ways to reach bhagavan.

Any one can follow sri vaishnava sampradayam but everyone cannot learn Agama sasthra.

Basically, sri vaishnavas are different from vaikanasas.

on November 22, 2022
Basically, sri vaishnavas are different from vaikanasas.From Sundara Ramanuja dasan

Swami,

I did have this doubt. 

Basically, devareer is saying that VaikhAnasAs are not RAmAnuja Sambandhis, hence not Sri Vaishnavites?? 

Agama teachs how to worship bhagavan in temples while sampradayam tells philosophy, siddantam and ways to reach bhagavan.From Sundara Ramanuja dasan

But how can the worshipping modes and the core philosophy (siddhAntam) contradict each other?

Shouldn’t the temples and the worshipping modes be in consonance with the siddhAntam, 

– Adiyen

Show more replies
  • Liked by
Reply
Cancel